Buyers’ perceptions of the tobacco retail sector are shifting as a result of new price transparency. Customers are able to make better purchasing decisions when they understand how the price of a product is affected, and can identify any disparities between brands. Clear pricing puts pressure on businesses to keep accurate records, outline what they are charging, and abide by the regulations.
This focus on discount smokes echoes a broader concern of people with their home spending and the increasing “prices of products bought every day.” But an advertised lower price does not necessarily equate to a lower end-of-bill price, and equitable comparison of advertised prices may not be possible. To enable consumers to appreciate the importance of transparency to consumers, retailers and regulators, they should become familiar with how pricing of tobacco is determined.
Understanding Tobacco Prices in Canada
The price of tobacco in Canada is made up of a number of cost factors: Federal taxes known as excise taxes, provincial and territorial tobacco taxes (PTT), provincial sales tax (PST), and what is retained in the supply chain by tobacco businesses. The components used are different on each product and each region, and as a result may be available at different prices throughout the country. In Canada, there are two different retail prices for tobacco products.
When reliable and complete information is available for a reliable cost-to-service comparison, these differences are more evident with price transparency. Customers can identify which portions of the price difference are tax-related, and which are due to differing business decisions by retailers, rather than just concluding that all price differences stem from a business decision. This is also one way to understand how a price is not the same in one province as in another.
What Price Transparency Means for Retailers
Taxes, supply prices, local competition and legal restrictions constitute the taxes, supply costs, local competition and strict legal restrictions that create market conditions for retailers. Consistent pricing ensures accurate bookkeeping, answers customer questions and minimises checkout hassles. Also, the owner will gain a better understanding of how fluctuations in the costs of manufacturing operations will affect their business.
Here are practical considerations to be taken into account in the setting of responsible pricing:
- Accurate records
- Clear transactions
- Regulatory compliance
- Responsible communication
The Importance of Governmental Regulation
Two areas in which federal and provincial governments have an impact on the retail price of tobacco include taxes and the regulations around tobacco sales and restrictions on product promotion. The federal Tobacco and Vaping Products Act prescribes standards for advertising tobacco and gives indications for price information. There are additional rules, too, that retailers should be aware of through the provincial and territorial rules.
For example, Ontario’s tobacco tax system has provincial-era taxes on tobacco in addition to federal excise taxes on tobacco and the applicable sales tax. Differences across the Canadian market are due to other jurisdictions having different tax structures and/or retail requirements. Retailers need to keep up-to-date official advice rather than referencing outdated prices, outdated versions of official advice, or assumptions that they could base food prices on a different province.
In conclusion, price transparency is helping drive more awareness around costs, accurate pricing and understanding about the price of tobacco in Canada. The advantage is that it helps organisations of retail companies to be more legally compliant. Regulations and market dynamics will change. So, information will be important to help understand the differences in tobacco prices across Canada.